|Don’t Milk Charter Schools for Pension Contributions|
By: James M. Hohman,
|April 03, 2012|
Michigan’s school administrators are right to complain about the high costs of state-mandated pensions for school employees, but they make the wrong prescriptions for remedying the problem. A recent article by Kalamazoo Gazette education reporter Julie Mack gives an illustration of the problem.
In the piece, Mack points out that the 24.46 percent of payroll that schools are required to contribute to the Michigan Public School Employees’ Retirement System is unsustainable and is draining school resources. But the legislators and school officials she interviews are wrong when they propose the system could be fixed by corralling public charter schools and school contractors to pay into MPSERS.
Currently, most charter school employees, because they are not technically employed directly by charter school boards, do not participate in MPSERS. Nor do any other school employees who are employed by private contractors. In lieu of participating in MPSERS, most charter school and support service contractors offer employees retirement benefits through 401(k) retirement accounts or some other defined-contribution retirement system.
Michigan’s large and growing unfunded school pension liabilities are the primary cause of high MPSERS contribution rates. Payments on unfunded liabilities are half of the total contribution. The state has unfunded liabilities for a couple of reasons, but the most significant is inaccurate assumptions about investments growth. The state assumes a return of 8 percent on pension funds it invested, but in the past 14 years these funds have only yielded an average annual return of 5.4 percent. The disparity between what the state has saved and what it is required to pay out in retirement benefits is now $17.6 billion.
Indeed, the unfunded liabilities have grown 6,500 percent since 2000, when MPSERS maintained a relatively-modest $246 million gap.
There’s no way around the fact that the state has to come up with this $17.6 billion. It doesn’t need to do this right away, however, and it is currently spreading the payments out over the next 26 years. But even under the state’s backloaded method for paying down this debt, the annual payment is still $1.05 billion, according to the state’s most recent actuary report.
And this $1.05 billion needs to be paid regardless of how many employees are in the system.
Current state policy is to charge it as a percentage of payroll, but there are alternatives. For instance, the state could directly pay MPSERS unfunded liabilities, perhaps with money otherwise directed to districts’ foundation allowances. (This is not unprecedented — prior to proposal A, the state directly paid most MPSERS contributions.)
Still, the fact that there are fewer employees in the system does not impact MPSERS’s unfunded liability problem that the state created for itself.
In fact, more parents choosing charter schools and districts opting to contract out for noninstructional services have actually lowered MPSERS’s total unfunded liabilities. Had employees at charter schools and school contractors been part of the pension system from day one, the state would have developed a larger school pension liability.
But pointing to the charter schools and contractors is a convenient excuse for established school interests. They’ve both been bogeymen for school unions, and school officials frequently gripe about charter schools — charters threaten the monopolized school market school officials have grown accustomed to.
Partially to their credit, however, pension reforms take a long time to have material fiscal effects. The state’s calculated costs to prefund benefits are small compared to the costs to provide benefits already earned and underfunded. It is also difficult to address the benefits already earned: pension benefits are protected by the state Constitution. Requiring others to pay for those benefits is a way to instantly lower MPSERS contribution rates, but it does not fix the unfunded liability problem. It ignores the structural problems and shifts responsibility for the costs of the problem.
Michigan’s school pension policies allow the state to get service from employees now and pay for it later. Unfortunately for the state and for school districts, later has arrived. Over the long term, this can be fixed by converting to a defined-contribution retirement system, which does not allow the state to pass pension costs to the next generation.
Public school officials, their employees and taxpayers alike should support a plan that fulfills the promises that are made to employees without becoming an excessive burden.
James M. Hohman is assistant director of fiscal policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a research and educational institute headquartered in Midland, Mich. Permission to reprint in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author and the Center are properly cited.
A Lansing charter school is in danger of closing, but charter advocates say it's not an indictment of the charter model
'Blended learning' charter high school impresses one Grand Rapids lawmaker, another raises concerns
Grand Valley State University expands eastward with new Detroit education, business center
Detroit business leaders support 'skunk works'-like groups in Michigan government
For-Profit Experiment Plays Out in Two Mich. Districts
Politics Alive and Well in Public Schools
MI school district to destroy building rather than sell to charter group
School Marketing is A-OK
Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder says lower-cost schools team 'not an official project'
'Skunk works' scuttled? Michigan schools chief Mike Flanagan to lead technology discussion
Don't Trust Ed-Trust on Charter Schools Group seeks ed reform, but misses mark on charters
Some charter schools focus on quality. Others focus on marketing. Guess which ones are winning.
Senator Warren Announces Reintroduction of Ban on For-Profit Schools
Covenant House Michigan buying Campau Park Elementary for $400,000
New strategies needed to improve Michigan charter schools, group says WITH VIDEO
Michigan's public education system getting schooled by other states
Education reform group forges voucher-like plan for Michigan
Report outlines six steps needed to bring Michigan schools in line with rest of the country
Eastern Michigan University issues charters for three schools
Over 100 Michigan charter schools to be represented at job fair at Novi showplace
Some Michigan schools could get $134 per kid boost under budget plan
Ann Arbor school board to vote Wednesday on 5-hour time limits
Guest column: Charter schools showing innovation needed to 'dig state out of educational hole'
Northern Michigan Arts: Northwest Academy Band Heads To DC
Michigan Charter School Conference
Albion Public Schools officials talk charter schools as way to fix $1 million budget deficit in 2013-14
Michigan may drop foreign language rule for schools
Marvin Sapp’s performance arts charter school slated to grow this fall; adding grades pre-K to 5th
Michigan House OKs failing school oversight bill
New charter schools find niches
Lansing School District comes through for Shabazz: 'This is family'
New Charter School in Ferndale Hosts Meeting Tonight
Marvin Sapp's performance arts charter school slated to grow this fall; adding grades pre-K to 5th
Former charter school director gets probation for lying about student enrollment
Michigan school districts feel pinch as deficits grow
More on Authorizer Accountability in Michigan
Group plans charter school serving elite athletes
GILBERT: Charter school movement firing back at critics
Character Education Seen as Student-Achievement Tool
Study: For-profit charter schools perform at or above non-profit peers
Straight cash: Some Michigan school admins see big bucks